Why Still Speak of a Preferred Future
The phrase "preferred future" can be dangerous. So why do we still need it? Wrapping up the series, a look at what speculative design leaves us and a second look at the phrase "the first thread of utopia."
The first piece of this series contained this sentence: “It’s about finding, in the utopia given to us, its first thread. The single most ideal future.”
Reading it again after the whole series, the sentence feels rather precarious. Dunne & Raby stressed bringing out many possibilities to open up debate rather than making predictions, and United Micro Kingdoms chose none of its four societies as the right answer. Voros’s cone showed that preference is a value judgment that differs from person to person, and Prado and Oliveira asked who exactly that “we” is. After hearing all of this, can we still speak of “the single ideal future”?
In this piece, rather than throwing the sentence away, I’d like to read it again in a revised way.
Why We Shouldn’t Stop Speaking
There’s something to ask first. What happens if nobody speaks of a preferred future? The future doesn’t arrive neutrally. The default takes its place.
As we saw in the third piece, a forecast that “it’ll happen that way anyway” passes without debate while carrying a value judgment inside it. Even now, countless companies and institutions are speaking of their own “better future” in the form of products, investments, and ads. If designers fall silent out of caution, preference doesn’t disappear; someone else’s preference simply comes true without being questioned.
In the first piece, I said that because we tend to react more strongly to negative stimuli, we readily envision the future as a dystopia. Dystopias are clearly useful as warnings. But someone who only knows what to avoid can’t say where to go. The methods of design fiction make it easy to create warnings, but drawing, convincingly, a world people would gladly live in is far harder. That’s why it’s all the more worth attempting.
A Direction, Not a Finished Product
Then how can we handle the danger? Three conditions come to mind.
First, treat utopia as a direction, not a blueprint. The moment you draw the future as a finished plan, anyone who doesn’t fit it becomes an error. A direction, on the other hand, can keep being corrected. That’s why, of the first piece’s expressions, the more important word is probably “thread” rather than “utopia.” A thread points not to an end but to the start of unraveling something.
Second, reveal the subject. Instead of “the path society should take,” say “I want this future for these reasons.” A preference stated as one person’s proposal can be argued against, but a preference spoken in the name of society is hard to argue against. Stating your own position is more honest than pretending to be neutral.
Third, write down the costs too. Any future is a cost to someone. Write down who is disadvantaged in that future and whether they had a chance to speak. If you can’t fill in this item, it’s probably a sign you haven’t thought it through enough yet.
Rewriting the Last Sentence
Seen this way, “the single most ideal future” can’t mean a right answer that already exists. Instead, the phrase can be read as a kind of attitude: in the face of countless possible futures, not retreating into “they all have their own value,” but stating, with reasons, the direction you believe is best as far as you know now, and being ready to revise it when told you’re wrong. In other words, “single” isn’t a conclusion but a responsible choice that has to be made each time.
Design has always worked this way. You can lay out dozens of drafts, but in the end you ship one to users, you have to explain why you chose it, and after shipping, you revise it again. As I said in the first piece, design has sought the best outcome within given conditions and goals. Speculative design shows that those conditions themselves can change, and that the scope in which we ask what is best can extend beyond products to society and the era.
So the answer to this series’ opening question, “What is speculative design?”, can be summed up like this. It isn’t a technique for predicting the future. It’s showing, through objects, that the world as it is now isn’t the only possible world, and then asking what kind of world we want. And I believe that the work of trying to answer that question is also part of the designer’s job.